Our Menu

Soups & Salads

Red Beans & Rice

$9.26

House Bisque

$12.77

Lobster or jumbo lump crab.

Cajun Gumbo

$10.64

Cajun Gumbo with Chicken and Sausage.

House or Caesar

$6.89

“The Wedge”

$9.66

Bacon, red onion, carrots, tomatoes, ranch vinaigrette or choice of dressing.

Strawberry Spinach

$11.34

Strawberries, dried cranberries, mango, feta, candied pecans, balsamic vinaigrette.

Schafer’s Salad

$13.42

Avocado, boiled egg, cucumbers, tomatoes, feta carrots, mangos, onion, bacon.

"The Greek"

$12.32

Cucumbers, tomatoes, feta, onion, kalamata olives, bell peppers, pepperoncini, house Greek dressing.

Appetizers

Deviled Eggs

$7.91

Six house made deviled eggs over a bed of salad with tangy house balsamic dressing.

Meatloaf Balls

$10.97

Over garlic whipped mashed potatoes, covered in brown sugar ketchup glaze.

Fried Risotto Balls

$12.59

Chef’s sundried tomato pesto, garlic whipped mashed potatoes. (limited availability)

Flatbreads

$9.96

Local baked flatbreads with house marinara pesto sauce, pepperoni or margherita.

Filet Bites

$16.77

Filet mignon & ribeye ends over onion strings with house honey mustard.

Creole Crab Dip

$13.88

The original favorite cream cheese based dip with two kinds of crabmeat, dry sherry, bell peppers, tomatoes and cajun spices served with warm tortilla chips.

Fried Calamari

$18.52

Kimchi aioli, bell peppers.

Blackened Shrimp

$19.81

Cajun blackened shrimp, garlic whipped mashed potatoes, brown butter sauce.

Schafer's Crab Cake

$19.68

90% crabmeat, 10% filling, “Best in town”.

Seared Ahi Tuna

$17.91

Blackened & seared served with a sweet ginger soy vinaigrette.

Poke Bowl

$18.19

Salmon or Tuna tossed in House Citrus Soy Sauce, Avocados, Mangos, Cucumber, Red Cabbage, topped with Siracha Mayo and Sesame Seeds.

Seafood Stuffed Avocado

$18.79

Avocado Halves stuffed with Crabmeat and Boiled Shrimp tossed in remoulade dressing.

Tacos

Islander Tacos

$13.52/+

Serrano garlic sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, jack cheese, cilantro, topped with mango pico de gallo, blackened, grilled or fried | Catfish $13.52 / Redfish $16.68 / Shrimp $13.52 / Mahi $16.68

Keto Tacos

$13.57/+

Avocado halves stuffed with choice of protein & all the traditional taco toppings, blackened or grilled | Catfish $13.57 / Redfish $16.73 / Shrimp $13.57 / Mahi $16.73

Redfish Tacos

$14.93

Serrano Garlic Sauce, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Jack Cheese, Cilantro, Purple Cabbage, Blacked, Grilled or Fried

From the Sea … Mostly

Citrus Glazed Salmon

$36.99

Orange citrus glaze over jasmine rice.

Blackened Redfish

$39.89

Signature brown butter sauce topped with blackened cajun shrimp.

Fried Catfish Platter

$22.28

Jumbo filet cornbread battered.

Coconut Shrimp

$26.97

8 shiner bock battered, spicy house orange marmalade sauce.

Fried Shrimp Platter

$26.97

12 jumbo shrimp cajun season battered.

Snapper Pontchartrain

$39.89

Mushroom, jumbo lump crabmeat, cajun seasoning in a white wine cream sauce.

Mango Mahi Mahi

$34.89

Parmesan panko crusted fried, mango pico de gallo, jalapeno honey pepper jelly.

Panko Crusted Grouper

$34.89

Parmesan panko breaded & pan fried, spicy orange marmalade tamarind reduction over citrus jasmine rice.

Redfish Piccata

$34.89

Classic rich creamy piccata sauce.

Redfish Schafer

$39.77

Jumbo lump crabmeat, angel hair pasta, asparagus bits, diced tomatoes, sliced mushrooms, tossed in a chardonnay, garlic, lemon butter cream sauce. “Composed dish”.