Our Menu
Soups & Salads
Choice of Dressing: Honey Mustard, Buttermilk Ranch Vinaigrette, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Greek, House Balsamic Vinaigrette • Add: Chicken $6.99, Shrimp $8.97, Tuna $9.71, or Salmon $9.99
Red Beans & Rice
$9.26
House Bisque
$12.77
Lobster or jumbo lump crab.
Cajun Gumbo
$10.64
Cajun Gumbo with Chicken and Sausage.
House or Caesar
$6.89
“The Wedge”
$9.66
Bacon, red onion, carrots, tomatoes, ranch vinaigrette or choice of dressing.
Strawberry Spinach
$11.34
Strawberries, dried cranberries, mango, feta, candied pecans, balsamic vinaigrette.
Schafer’s Salad
$13.42
Avocado, boiled egg, cucumbers, tomatoes, feta carrots, mangos, onion, bacon.
"The Greek"
$12.32
Cucumbers, tomatoes, feta, onion, kalamata olives, bell peppers, pepperoncini, house Greek dressing.
Appetizers
Deviled Eggs
$7.91
Six house made deviled eggs over a bed of salad with tangy house balsamic dressing.
Meatloaf Balls
$10.97
Over garlic whipped mashed potatoes, covered in brown sugar ketchup glaze.
Fried Risotto Balls
$12.59
Chef’s sundried tomato pesto, garlic whipped mashed potatoes. (limited availability)
Flatbreads
$9.96
Local baked flatbreads with house marinara pesto sauce, pepperoni or margherita.
Filet Bites
$16.77
Filet mignon & ribeye ends over onion strings with house honey mustard.
Creole Crab Dip
$13.88
The original favorite cream cheese based dip with two kinds of crabmeat, dry sherry, bell peppers, tomatoes and cajun spices served with warm tortilla chips.
Fried Calamari
$18.52
Kimchi aioli, bell peppers.
Blackened Shrimp
$19.81
Cajun blackened shrimp, garlic whipped mashed potatoes, brown butter sauce.
Schafer's Crab Cake
$19.68
90% crabmeat, 10% filling, “Best in town”.
Seared Ahi Tuna
$17.91
Blackened & seared served with a sweet ginger soy vinaigrette.
Poke Bowl
$18.19
Salmon or Tuna tossed in House Citrus Soy Sauce, Avocados, Mangos, Cucumber, Red Cabbage, topped with Siracha Mayo and Sesame Seeds.
Seafood Stuffed Avocado
$18.79
Avocado Halves stuffed with Crabmeat and Boiled Shrimp tossed in remoulade dressing.
Cold Bar
Oysters on the Half Shell (GF)
$12.99/+
1/2 Dozen $12.99 or Full Dozen $19.99
Rockefeller Oyster
$20.64
Creamy garlic spinach, malte parmesan cheese & bacon bits.
Schafer's Ceviche
$17.87
Fresh fish, boiled gulf shrimp, lime juice, pico de gallo, topped with sliced avocado served with warm tortilla chips.
Shrimp Cocktail
$16.71
Cajun boiled shrimp served cold with cocktail sauce and horseradish.
Tacos
Islander Tacos
$13.52/+
Serrano garlic sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, jack cheese, cilantro, topped with mango pico de gallo, blackened, grilled or fried | Catfish $13.52 / Redfish $16.68 / Shrimp $13.52 / Mahi $16.68
Keto Tacos
$13.57/+
Avocado halves stuffed with choice of protein & all the traditional taco toppings, blackened or grilled | Catfish $13.57 / Redfish $16.73 / Shrimp $13.57 / Mahi $16.73
Redfish Tacos
$14.93
Serrano Garlic Sauce, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Jack Cheese, Cilantro, Purple Cabbage, Blacked, Grilled or Fried
From the Sea … Mostly
Each come with your choice of (2) a la carte sides.
Citrus Glazed Salmon
$36.99
Orange citrus glaze over jasmine rice.
Blackened Redfish
$39.89
Signature brown butter sauce topped with blackened cajun shrimp.
Fried Catfish Platter
$22.28
Jumbo filet cornbread battered.
Coconut Shrimp
$26.97
8 shiner bock battered, spicy house orange marmalade sauce.
Fried Shrimp Platter
$26.97
12 jumbo shrimp cajun season battered.
Snapper Pontchartrain
$39.89
Mushroom, jumbo lump crabmeat, cajun seasoning in a white wine cream sauce.
Mango Mahi Mahi
$34.89
Parmesan panko crusted fried, mango pico de gallo, jalapeno honey pepper jelly.
Panko Crusted Grouper
$34.89
Parmesan panko breaded & pan fried, spicy orange marmalade tamarind reduction over citrus jasmine rice.
Redfish Piccata
$34.89
Classic rich creamy piccata sauce.
Redfish Schafer
$39.77
Jumbo lump crabmeat, angel hair pasta, asparagus bits, diced tomatoes, sliced mushrooms, tossed in a chardonnay, garlic, lemon butter cream sauce. “Composed dish”.
Mom's Meatloaf
$23.68
Mom’s special topped with thick brown sugar ketchup glaze.
Schafer’s House Pasta
$25.89
Creamy Alfredo sauce mixed with crawfish tails, blackened shrimp, and grilled chicken topped with parmesan cheese. “Composed dish”.
Chickn’ Fried Chickn’
$25.71
Rich creamy andouille sausage gravy.
Chicken Parmesan
$24.96
Italian bread crumbs, pan fried, spicy marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese. “Composed dish”.
Lemon Pepper Chickn’
$23.97
Lemon pepper seasoned chicken breast topped with creamy lemon butter sauce over citrus rice.
Mexi-Cajun Chicken
$24.99
Grilled Chicken Breast over Cajun Red Beans & Rice smothered in creamy Queso & Pico De Gallo.
The Keto Grill
Comes with your choice of (2) a la carte sides.
Chicken
$19.82
Tuna Steak
$23.97
Salmon
$28.22
Mahi Mahi
$28.22
Snapper
$29.97
Redfish
$29.97
A La Carte Sides
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
$7.50
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
$5.50
Au Gratin Potatoes
$7.50
Sauteed Green Beans
$7.50
Lemon Butter Asparagus
$7.50
Spicy Mac & Cheese
$7.50
Southwest Roasted Corn
$5.50
Sauteed Vegetables
$6.50
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.50
French Fries
$5.00
Onion Rings
$5.50
Wavy Fries
$6.50
Meat Lovers
Each come with your choice of (2) a la carte sides.
Prime Pork Ribeye
$26.87
Smothered in a creamy green peppercorn sauce, laying on a bed of garlic whipped mashed potatoes.
6 oz Filet Mignon
$44.89
14 oz Ribeye
$52.94
Grilled Shrimp (5)
$7.97
Jumbo Lump Crab Meat
$9.94
Sandwiches & Wraps
Served with Fries and / or Rings... Sub Wavy Fries $2.99
Schafer Burger
$17.89
Jalapeno cheddar sourdough bun, bacon, mushroom, jalapeno, avocado, pepper jack cheese, zesty garlic aioli.
Texas Cheese Steak
$18.56
Shaved ribeye, sautéed onions, bell peppers, jalapenos, mushrooms, 3 melted cheeses.
Cajun Po Boy
$14.32
Fried shrimp, fried catfish, or combo house siracha remoulade dressing on a french baguette.
Classic Cheese Burger
$14.71
American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, kosher pickle chips.
Zydeco Shrimp Wrap
$16.68
Carnival coleslaw, fried shrimp, tamarind reduction, avocado ranch dressing, wrapped in a sun dried tomato basil flour tortilla.
The King Ranch Sandwich
$17.89
House brined & marinated fried chicken breast, melted pepperjack cheese, avocado ranch & tamarind chipotle glaze topped with sliced avocados.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$15.89
Lettuce, Tomato, Carnival Coleslaw, House Buttermilk Ranch Dressing
Dessert
New Orleans Bread Pudding
$9.89
Chef’s special, baked fresh daily…. Recipe straight out of New Orleans
Crème Brûlée
$9.89
Custard Topped with Torched Sugar and Fresh Berries
Chocolate Cake
$9.89
Chocolate Cake layered with Chocolate Mousse, topped with Shaved Chocolate bits, strawberries, and strawberry glaze
Vanilla Cheesecake
$9.89
Paired with strawberries, strawberry glaze, and whipped cream
Key Lime Pie
$8.99
Chocolate Martini
$15.00
40 Year Tawny Port
$24.00
Lunch Specials
Under $12.00 Lunch Specials • Tuesday - Friday 11 AM - 4 PM
Lunch Chopped Salad
$11.99
1/2 portion avocado, boiled egg, cucumbers, tomatoes feta, carrots, mangos, onion, bacon.
Lunch Meatloaf Plate
$12.99
1/2 portion. Ketchup based brown sugar glaze, choice of one side.
Soup & Sandwich
$12.99
Choose Between Lobster or Jumbo Lump Crab Bisque & Gumbo with half a “Po Boy”. Choice of Catfish, Shrimp, or Combo.
Schafer Burger
$12.99
Bacon, mushroom, jalapeno, avocado, pepper jack cheese, zesty garlic aioli.
Soup & Salad
$12.99
Soup of choice with a Caesar or House salad.
Lunch Greek Salad
$9.99
1/2 portion cucumbers, tomatoes, feta, onion, olives bell peppers, pepperoncini, house greek dressing.
Lunch Fried Shrimp
$12.99
(6) Fried Shrimp served with fries and/or onion rings.
Lunch Coconut Shrimp
$12.99
(4) shiner bock battered, spicy house made orange marmalade sauce, served with fries and/or onion rings.
Cajun Po Boy
$12.99
Fried shrimp, catfish, or combo, house remoulade dressing, served with fries and/or onion rings.
Lunch Fish of the Day
$18.99
Grilled, blackened, or fried with choice of one side.
Lunch Fried Seafood Platter
$17.99
2 catfish filets, 6 shrimp, served with fries and/or onion rings.
Nightly Specials
Starts at 5 PM, limited availability or while supplies last | Dine-In Only | If you want to split a meal, we add $5.00
Tuesday
$26.98
Steak night | 6 oz Filet, 12 oz Ribeye or Pork Ribeye. Served with 2 sides & salad.
Wednesday
$16.97
Italian Night | Chicken Parmesan, served with Bolognese pasta and garlic bread
Wednesday
Wine Down Wednesday open to close | $4 House wine | $5 Seaglass
Thursday
$29.97
Crispy Redfish served with two sides.
Friday
$49.99
Redfish Shafer & Lobster Tail. Jumbo Lump Crabmeat, Angel Hair Pasta, Asparagus bits, Diced Tomatoes, Sliced Mushrooms, tossed in a Chardonnay, Garlic, Lemon Butter Cream Sauce “Composed Dish”.
Saturday
$49.99
Steak & Lobster - 6 oz Filet & Lobster Tail served with 2 sides.
Sunday
$15.99
Sunday Supper. Spicy Marinara Pasta &
Meat Balls
Meat Balls
Small Bites
Tuesday - Thursday 3 PM - 6 PM
Deviled Eggs
$5.96
Creole Crab Dip
$10.93
Filet Bites
$9.91
Dozen Oysters
$14.92
Ceviche
$12.88
Seared Tuna
$12.91
Drinks
Tuesday - Thursday 3 PM - 6 PM
Spicy Cucumber Martini
$9.00
Good Old Fashioned
$9.00
Blueberry Cucumber Martini
$9.00
Lavender Lemon Drop
$9.00
Skinny Rita
$9.00
Domestic Beers
$4.00
Import Beers
$5.00
Tax and gratuity will be added to the total. Extra fee for after hours. Pricing is based on quantity, time needed on or off site and time of delivery. Final rates will be quoted separately.
Entrees
*Items served with 2 sides and a warm dinner roll.
Meatloaf
Topped with brown sugar glaze.
Chicken Piccata
Grilled chicken breast topped with a classic rich creamy piccata sauce.
Smothered Hamburger Steak
Rich brown gravy sauteed mushrooms and minced onions.
Prime Pork Ribeye
Chargrilled and smothered in a creamy green peppercorn sauce.
Blackened Redfish
Blackened Redfish, topped with our signature brown butter sauce.
Redfish Piccata
Grilled Redfish topped with a classic rich creamy piccata sauce.
Pasta
*Pastas are a composed dish with no sides.
Chicken Alfredo Pasta
House seasoned grilled diced chicken blended with creamy rich alfredo, served with Texas garlic bread.
Spicy Marinara & Chicken Pasta
House seasoned grilled diced chicken blended with Bolognese style spicy marinara sauce & Texas garlic bread. Substitute Shrimp for additional price.
Lasagna
Served with Texas garlic bread.
Sandwiches & Tacos
*Served with bagged chips. Sides can be added.
Outrigger Taco Meal - 2 Tacos / 3 Tacos
Choice of fish, shrimp, beef or chicken tacos | Lettuce, tomato, cilantro, cheese, serrano aioli, Outriggers taco sauce (on the side). Made ready to eat or all toppings on the side.
Texas Cheeseburger
8 oz. | All toppings are served on the side | Lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickle slices, mayo, mustard packets.
Zydeco Chicken Wrap
Carnival coleslaw, grilled chicken, tamarind reduction, king ranch dressing, wrapped in a sun-dried tomato flour tortilla.
Sides
Garlic Whipped Mashed Potatoes
Spicy Mac & Cheese
Green Beans
Caramelized Carrots
Mixed Vegetables
Jasmine Rice
Southwest Roasted Corn
Red Beans & Rice
Drinks
Bottled Water
Coke
Diet Coke
Dr Pepper
Sprite
Brisk Lemon Tea
Desserts
Desserts
Available upon request.