Our Menu
Soups & Salads
Choice of Dressing: Honey Mustard, Buttermilk Ranch Vinaigrette, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Greek, House Balsamic Vinaigrette • Add: Chicken $6.99, Shrimp $8.97, Tuna $9.71, or Salmon $9.99
Red Beans & Rice
$8.96
House Bisque
$12.77
Lobster or jumbo lump crab.
Cajun Gumbo
$8.85
House or Caesar
$5.89
“The Wedge”
$7.46
Bacon, red onion, carrots, tomatoes, ranch vinaigrette or choice of dressing.
Strawberry Spinach
$10.34
Strawberries, dried cranberries, mango, feta, candied pecans, balsamic vinaigrette.
Schafer’s “Chopped”
$12.42
Avocado, boiled egg, cucumbers, tomatoes, feta carrots, mangos, onion, bacon.
"The Greek"
$10.32
Cucumbers, tomatoes, feta, onion, kalamata olives bell peppers, pepperoncini, house Greek dressing.
Appetizers
Deviled Eggs
$7.26
Six house made deviled eggs over a bed of salad with tangy house balsamic dressing.
Meatloaf Balls
$10.47
Over garlic whipped mashed potatoes, covered in brown sugar ketchup glaze.
Fried Risotto Balls
$11.35
Chef’s sundried tomato pesto, garlic whipped mashed potatoes. (limited availability)
Flatbreads Return !!!
$9.96
Local baked flatbreads with house marinara pesto sauce, pepperoni or margherita.
Filet Bites
$14.47
Filet mignon & ribeye ends over onion strings with house honey mustard.
Creole Crab Dip
$12.88
The original favorite cream cheese based dip with two kinds of crabmeat, dry sherry, bell peppers, tomatoes and cajun spices served with warm tortilla chips.
Coconut Mahi Nuggets
$14.81
Coconut crusted deep fried, spicy orange marmalade.
Fried Calamari
$17.79
Kimchi aioli, bell peppers.
Blackened Shrimp
$17.41
Cajun blackened shrimp, garlic whipped mashed potatoes, brown butter sauce.
Schafer's Crab Cake
$18.68
90% crabmeat, 10% filling, “Best in town”.
Seared Ahi Tuna
$14.66
Blackened & seared served with a sweet ginger soy vinaigrette.
Truffle Risotto Balls
Fried risotto balls served with basil pesto sauce and parmesan cheese.
Cold Bar
Oysters on the Half Shell (GF)
$12.99/+
1/2 Dozen $12.99 or Full Dozen $19.99
Rockefeller Oyster
$18.64
Creamy garlic spinach, malte parmesan cheese & bacon bits.
Schafer's Ceviche
$14.67
Fresh fish, boiled gulf shrimp, lime juice, pico de gallo, topped with sliced avocado served with warm tortilla chips.
Shrimp Cocktail
$15.71
Cajun boiled shrimp served cold with cocktail sauce and horseradish.
Tacos
Trout Tacos
$12.97
Serrano garlic sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, jack cheese, cilantro, blackened, grilled or fried.
Islander Tacos
$13.52/+
Serrano garlic sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, jack cheese, cilantro, topped with mango pico de gallo, blackened, grilled or fried | Catfish $13.52 / Redfish $16.68 / Shrimp $13.52 / Mahi $16.68
Keto Tacos
$13.57/+
Avocado halves stuffed with choice of protein & all the traditional taco toppings, blackened or grilled | Catfish $13.57 / Redfish $16.73 / Shrimp $13.57 / Mahi $16.73
From the Sea … Mostly
Each come with your choice of (2) a la carte sides.
Citrus Glazed Salmon
$31.99
Orange citrus glaze over jasmine rice.
Blackened Redfish
$37.39
Signature brown butter sauce topped with blackened cajun shrimp.
Fried Catfish Platter
$20.24
Jumbo filet cornbread battered.
Coconut Shrimp
$24.97
8 shiner bock battered, spicy house orange marmalade sauce.
Fried Shrimp Platter
$24.97
12 jumbo shrimp cajun season battered.
Snapper Pontchartrain
$38.63
Mushroom, jumbo lump crabmeat, cajun seasoning in a white wine cream sauce.
Mango Mahi Mahi
$31.49
Parmesan panko crusted fried, mango pico de gallo, jalapeno honey pepper jelly.
Panko Crusted Grouper
$31.99
Parmesan panko breaded & pan fried, spicy orange marmalade tamarind reduction over citrus jasmine rice.
Redfish Piccata
$29.99
Classic rich creamy piccata sauce.
Salmon Schafer
$37.56
Jumbo lump crabmeat, angel hair pasta, asparagus bits, diced tomatoes, sliced mushrooms, tossed in a chardonnay, garlic, lemon butter cream sauce. “Composed dish”.
Ma's Meatloaf
$20.68
Mom’s special topped with thick brown sugar ketchup glaze.
Schafer’s House Pasta
$21.57
Creamy Alfredo sauce mixed with crawfish tails, blackened shrimp, and grilled chicken topped with parmesan cheese. “Composed dish”.
Mango Chutney Chickn’
$20.31
Marinated grilled chicken mango chutney glaze, served over citrus jasmine rice.
Chickn’ Fried Chickn’
$20.71
Rich creamy andouille sausage gravy.
Chicken Parmesan
$19.86
Italian bread crumbs, pan fried, spicy marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese. “Composed dish”.
Lemon Pepper Chickn’
$19.44
Lemon pepper seasoned chicken breast topped with creamy lemon butter sauce over citrus rice.
The Keto Grill
Comes with your choice of (2) a la carte sides.
Chicken
$17.82
Tuna Steak
$20.97
Salmon
$26.22
Mahi Mahi
$26.22
Snapper
$29.97
Redfish
$29.97
A La Carte Sides
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
$7.50
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
$7.50
Au Gratin Potatoes
$7.50
Sauteed Green Beans
$7.50
Lemon Butter Asparagus
$7.50
Spicy Mac & Cheese
$7.50
Southwest Roasted Corn
$5.50
Sauteed Vegetables
$6.50
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.50
Loaded Tater Tots
$8.50
Battered French Fries
$4.50
Onion Rings
$5.50
Meat Lovers
Each come with your choice of (2) a la carte sides.
Prime Pork Ribeye
$22.75
Smothered in a creamy green peppercorn sauce, laying on a bed of garlic whipped mashed potatoes.
6 oz Filet Mignon
$39.67
14 oz Ribeye
$49.97
Grilled Shrimp (5)
$7.97
Jumbo Lump Crab Meat
$9.94
Sandwiches & Wraps
Served with Fries and / or Rings.
Schafer Burger
$16.47
Jalapeno cheddar sourdough bun, bacon, mushroom, jalapeno, avocado, pepper jack cheese, zesty garlic aioli.
Texas Cheese Steak
$18.56
Shaved ribeye, sautéed onions, bell peppers, jalapenos, mushrooms, 3 melted cheeses.
Cajun Po Boy
$13.32
Fried shrimp, fried catfish, or combo house siracha remoulade dressing on a french baguette.
Classic Cheese Burger
$13.71
American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, kosher pickle chips.
Zydeco Shrimp Wrap
$12.68
Carnival coleslaw, fried shrimp, tamarind reduction, avocado ranch dressing, wrapped in a sun dried tomato basil flour tortilla.
Cajun Salmon Wrap
$17.82
Lettuce, tomato, carnival coleslaw, mango pico de gallo, tamarind reduction.
The King Ranch Sandwich
$16.14
House brined & marinated fried chicken breast, melted pepperjack cheese, avocado ranch & tamarind chipotle glaze topped with sliced avocados.
Dessert
New Orleans Bread Pudding
$8.99
Chef’s special, baked fresh daily…. Recipe straight out of New Orleans
Crème Brûlée
$8.99
Chocolate Cake
$8.99
Vanilla Cheesecake
$8.99
Key Lime Pie
$8.99
Chocolate Martini
$13.00
40 Year Tawny Port
$19.00
Lunch Specials
Under $12.00 Lunch Specials • Tuesday - Friday 11 AM - 4 PM
Lunch Chopped Salad
$9.99
1/2 portion avocado, boiled egg, cucumbers, tomatoes feta, carrots, mangos, onion, bacon.
Lunch Meatloaf Plate
$11.99
1/2 portion. Ketchup based brown sugar glaze, choice of one side.
Soup & Sandwich
$10.99
Soup of choice & half a “Po Boy”.
Schafer Burger
$11.99
Bacon, mushroom, jalapeno, avocado, pepper jack cheese, zesty garlic aioli.
Soup & Salad
$10.99
Soup of choice, Caesar or House salad.
Lunch Greek Salad
$7.99
1/2 portion cucumbers, tomatoes, feta, onion, olives bell peppers, pepperoncini, house greek dressing.
Lunch Fried Shrimp
$11.99
(6) Fried Shrimp served with fries and/or onion rings.
Lunch Coconut Shrimp
$11.99
(4) shiner bock battered, spicy house made orange marmalade sauce, served with fries and/or onion rings.
Cajun Po Boy
$11.99
Fried shrimp, catfish, or combo, house remoulade dressing, served with fries and/or onion rings.
Lunch Fish of the Day
$15.99
Grilled, blackened, or fried with choice of one side.
Lunch Fried Seafood Platter
$14.99
2 catfish filets, 6 shrimp, served with fries and/or onion rings.
Nightly Specials
Starts at 5 PM, limited availability or while supplies last | Dine-In Only | If you want to split a meal, we add $5.00
Tuesday
$24.98
Steak night | 6 oz Filet, 12 oz Ribeye or Pork Ribeye. Served with 2 sides & salad.
Wednesday
$14.97
Italian Night | Chicken Parmesan, served with Bolognese pasta and garlic bread
Wednesday
Wine Down Wednesday open to close | $4 House wine | $5 Seaglass
Thursday
$25.97
Crispy Redfish served with two sides.
Friday
$44.99
Salmon Shafer & Lobster Tail. Jumbo Lump Crabmeat, Angel Hair Pasta, Asparagus bits, Diced Tomatoes, Sliced Mushrooms, tossed in a Chardonnay, Garlic, Lemon Butter Cream Sauce “Composed Dish”.
Saturday
$47.99
6 oz filet & lobster.
Sunday
$12.99
Sunday Supper. Spicy Marinara Pasta &
Meat Balls
Meat Balls
Small Bites
Tuesday - Thursday 3 PM - 6 PM
Deviled Eggs
$5.96
Creole Crab Dip
$10.93
Filet Bites
$9.91
Dozen Oysters
$14.92
Ceviche
$12.88
Seared Tuna
$12.91
Drinks
Tuesday - Thursday 3 PM - 6 PM
Spicy Cucumber Martini
$9.00
Good Old Fashioned
$9.00
Blueberry Cucumber Martini
$9.00
Lavender Lemon Drop
$9.00
Skinny Rita
$9.00
Domestic Beers
$4.00
Import Beers
$5.00